facebook

Skip links

 

Cottage Ownership vs. The Franklin Club: Which is Best for You?

So, you’re thinking about buying a cottage in Ontario—or maybe you already own one and are starting to question whether it’s worth the time, money, and effort. The idea of a peaceful retreat is appealing—lazy mornings by the water, evenings by the fire, and a break from city life. But is it really as carefree as it seems?

Before diving into cottage ownership, consider the realities: maintenance, property taxes, and unpredictable expenses can quickly turn that dream getaway into a year-round responsibility. Instead of dealing with the hassles, why not explore an alternative? The Franklin Club offers a seamless way to enjoy the outdoors—without the upkeep. Whether you crave weekend fishing trips, quiet nature escapes, or a welcoming community, The Franklin Club delivers all the benefits of cottage life without the burdens.

But before you start scouring cottage real estate listings, let’s talk about some of the realities of cottage ownership—and why joining The Franklin Club might be your better option.

The Dream vs. The Reality of Cottage Ownership

Owning a cottage is often seen as the ultimate escape, but the reality isn’t always as idyllic as it seems. While having a retreat in nature sounds appealing, it comes with significant responsibilities and hidden challenges.

1. The Hidden Costs

Owning a cottage is a major financial commitment. Beyond the purchase price, you’ll face property taxes, insurance, utilities, and ongoing maintenance. Seasonal upkeep—winterizing, dock repairs, septic systems, pest control—adds up quickly. Then there are inevitable renovations, turning what should be a relaxing getaway into an ongoing expense of both time and money.

2. Constant Maintenance

A second home means twice the upkeep. If your roof leaks, plumbing fails, or rodents move in, it’s up to you to handle it. Finding reliable service providers in cottage country isn’t always easy, and managing repairs remotely can be a headache. What starts as a peaceful retreat can quickly feel like another job.

3. More Work > Less Relaxation

Yard work, boat repairs, painting, deck staining, deep cleaning—cottage life often means spending weekends doing chores rather than unwinding. Instead of sipping coffee by the lake, you might be hauling firewood or troubleshooting plumbing issues. Over time, your escape from routine can start to feel like just another home to manage.

4. Crowds & Noise

Many dream of cottage life for the peace and quiet—but in reality, short-term rentals and increased tourism have made many Ontario cottage areas busier than ever. Loud neighbors, heavy boat traffic, and weekend party crowds can turn your tranquil retreat into a source of stress.

5. Changing Ecosystems & Wildlife 

Long-time cottage owners have noticed environmental shifts—climate change, overdevelopment, and human activity are affecting water quality and local wildlife. Once-thriving fishing spots may be struggling, and sightings of loons, deer, and other wildlife are becoming less common.

6. Seasonal Accessibility

Not all cottages are accessible year-round. Some require boat access, while others are located on unmaintained roads that become impassable in winter. Heavy snow, flooding, or ice buildup can leave you cut off when you need it most. Many owners find their costly getaway sits unused for months while expenses continue.

Why The Franklin Club Might Be the Better Option

If you love the outdoors, fishing, and escaping the city but don’t want the hassle of cottage ownership, The Franklin Club offers an exceptional alternative.

1. Zero Maintenance, Maximum Enjoyment – 365 Days a Year

At The Franklin Club, all you have to do is show up and enjoy. Spanning 200 acres of pristine nature, including Franklin Lake and private fishing ponds, the club provides a turn-key outdoor experience. No grass to cut, no cabin repairs—just relaxation and good company. The club’s staff handles all maintenance so you can focus on what matters: fishing, hiking, swimming, camping and unwinding.

2. A Cost-Effective Alternative

For a fraction of the cost of owning a cottage, membership grants you access to private, well-stocked waters and premium facilities—without the stress of property taxes, insurance, or costly upkeep. Plus, you can bring guests, whether family, friends, or colleagues, making every visit a shared experience. Whether you’re looking for a weekend getaway or a scenic spot for corporate retreats, The Franklin Club provides an unbeatable setting for relaxation and connection.

3. Exclusive Amenities & A Premium Experience

The Franklin Club is more than a fishing destination—it’s a year-round retreat designed for comfort and convenience. Members enjoy:

  • Fully stocked lakes and ponds with exceptional fishing opportunities for trophy sized trout
  • A web of hiking trials throughout the 200 acre property
  • A modern clubhouse with a full-service dining room, offering seasonal menus
  • A waterfront patio with a no-corkage policy—bring your favorite bottle and enjoy
  • Five guest suites and three camping sites (one with an electrical hookup)
  • Fire pits, propane BBQs, and modern well-maintained gathering spaces
  • Winter activities including, ice fishing, skating, hockey and cross-country skiing
  • Clubhouse rentals, meeting spaces, and on-site storage, including liquor lockers

Every detail is designed to make your time here effortless and enjoyable.

4. A Peaceful, Private Escape

With a cap of just 200 members, The Franklin Club offers a truly exclusive retreat—no crowded fishing spots, no noisy motorboats, just a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. Glide across the lake in a motorless boat, cast your line in undisturbed waters, and enjoy the sights and sounds of nature in a pristine setting.

5. A Hassle-Free Alternative to Cottage Ownership

Owning a cottage means long commutes, planning, maintenance, and unexpected costs. The Franklin Club eliminates those headaches. Located just 65 km from Toronto, it offers all the benefits of a cottage experience without the burdens of ownership.

Our dedicated staff ensures every visit is seamless, so you can focus on fishing, camping, boating, hiking, and making memories with loved ones. Whether you’re introducing the kids or grandkids to fishing, enjoying a quiet weekend escape, or gathering with friends, The Franklin Club makes outdoor enjoyment effortless and fun.

So, What’s the Best Choice for You?

Cottage ownership can be rewarding, but it comes with significant costs, maintenance, and time commitments. If you have the time, resources, and energy to manage a second property, it may be the right fit for you.

However, if you’re looking for a turnkey outdoor experience with less hassle, lower costs, and more flexibility, The Franklin Club offers an exclusive, stress-free alternative. With private, well-maintained nature trails, pristine waters, premium amenities, and a short 65 km commute from Toronto, it delivers everything you love about cottage life—without the burdens of ownership.

Before taking the leap into cottage ownership, consider what truly suits your lifestyle. You might find that The Franklin Club is exactly the escape you’ve been looking for.

Fin of fish just breaking surface of lake water

Curious to see what The Franklin Club has to offer?

Experience firsthand why so many outdoor enthusiasts prefer the ease, convenience, and quality of club membership over cottage ownership—schedule a visit today!

1
3 generations of Fly Fisherman - John Paterson
crosscountry skiing
Return to top of page